I’m usually not one to watch artsy movies made by dictator-directors, but my brother gave me a DVD of The Lighthouse and said I had to watch it. Plus it stars Willem Defoe, and I’m up to watch anything with Willem Defoe.
The premise of the movie is simple: two men are put on a desolate rock far from shore to man a lighthouse for four weeks, and they slowly lose their grip on reality. As a matter of fact, except for a few frames featuring a mermaid and an apparition, Defoe and Robert Pattinson are the only actors in this film.
My brother was right to call this an ‘experience’. The overall tone of the film was weird as the two men descended into madness, and it was easy to see that the director had a very specific vision. Like he wanted to make an explicit statement about the human psyche that only he could have dreamed of. When the movie was over, I half expected him to be in the corner, arms folded across his chest, and a smug ‘now do you see?’ grin.
For instance, there’s some scenes that just felt, you know, gratuitous. Like an entire two minutes of Pattinson’s character furiously masturbating to a wooden carving of a mermaid (nothing explicit is shown here). That’s just something that I could have lived without seeing.
Or the flashes of Pattinson’s character having sex with a mermaid. And not a harmless, Disney-fied version of a mermaid, but the actual deadly monster that sailors once feared. There was a ton of sexual overtones and scenes in this, which as aforementioned are surely all meant to make some kind of statement on the human psyche that only an artistic genius could have imagined.
And despite the length of the film (1 hour, 49 minutes) somehow it jumped into the thick of the plot too quickly. There was no grace period of the men still being normal, as almost immediately one of them began having visions and exhibiting signs of madness. Like they were mad before they even came to the island.
Oh, and the whole movie is shot in black and white.
As for the acting itself, Pattinson and Defoe knocked it out of the park. They are phenomenal actors and they gave a truly magnetic performance. But the movie itself was just really weird, it felt preachy but I wasn’t even sure what was being preached to me, and long.
So I can’t really recommend this one unless, as my brother described it, you’re in the mood for an ‘experience’.